"Needs a permanent spot" — American Idol fans react to Fantasia's return as a guest mentor

When Fantasia Barrino returned as a guest mentor for American Idol Season 23 this week, fans were ecstatic and filled with nostalgia. Rather than competing, the Grammy-winning singer, who won season 3 of the show, returned to the stage to mentor the current group of aspirants as they took on difficult Rock & Roll Hall of Fame standards. Viewers were reminded by her strong presence and wise counsel why she is still regarded as one of the most adored Idol contestants.

Fantasia engaged with the competitors on a profound emotional level in addition to providing technical advice. She urged them to overcome their nervousness, draw on their own experiences, and own the stage. Many of the Top 12 contestants stated that her words gave them the confidence to take chances in their performances, demonstrating how her genuineness and passion struck a chord with them. Fantasia was able to mentor emerging artists in the same way that she had done twenty years prior. Thus, it was a full-circle experience.

In addition to mentoring, Fantasia's soul-stirring rendition of her gospel classic "Have Your Way" lit up the Idol stage. Judges and spectators were in awe of the moving performance. Her vocals were acclaimed by fans, who also described the performance as a heavenly experience. Some even suggested that she ought to return to the show permanently.

An admirer of American Idol posted on X,

"Based on how Fantasia was able to help these contestants elevate their performances, it’s clear that Fantasia needs a permanent spot on #AmericanIdol"

Another fan shared on social media,

"I need them to make Fantasia a permanent judge on American Idol because she’s pulling something different out of all of these contestants this week. #AmericanIdol #Fantasia"

"Fantasia @TasiasWord is who I describe as a "Super Coach"!! She brings out things in Artist that they didn't even know they possess!! She should release some format with all that inspiration!! #Legend @AmericanIdol @carrieunderwood @LionelRichie #AmericanIdol #Music," another tweet read.

More fans talked about Fantasia's performance and her appearance in the latest episode of American Idol Season 23.

A netizen posted,

"Fantasia Barrino was by far the best mentor to serve on #AmericanIdol in forever. She gave great advice and wasn't afraid to correct the artists. The need to thank her for helping them sound their best. Wow. But-the voters got it wrong."

"Fantasia was such a great mentor tonight on #AmericanIdol. She really connected and guided every single contestant and gave such great advice. I need her back for the Finale!" another X user commented.

---

Fantasia performs "Have Your Way" in episode 14 of American Idol Season 23

In American Idol Season 23, Episode 14, Fantasia Barrino gave a stunning performance of her gospel ballad, "Have Your Way." The Top 12 candidates were revealed on April 20, 2025, but the main attraction was Fantasia's reappearance as a guest mentor and performer.

The audience was clearly captivated by her emotive delivery and wonderful singing. Fantasia reminded the audience why she is still regarded as an Idol icon with her unadulterated singing passion. Social media was inundated with compliments from fans, many of whom claimed she should have a regular role on the show.

---

Watch all the episodes of American Idol Season 23 on ABC.