High Potential Season 2 cast and character guide: Who's returning for the follow-up?

High Potential Season 2 arrives on ABC on September 16, 2025, throwing Morgan Gillory and the LAPD team into a new set of cases and family pressure. The show opens with Morgan still juggling three children and a role as an LAPD consultant. The trailer makes it clear that the season leans into a single, visible threat, i.e., the Game Maker, a figure from the Season 1 finale who keeps appearing in Morgan’s life and who she feels puts her children at risk.

The premiere episode, titled “Pawns,” shows Morgan trying to shield her kids while a new crime pulls her back into police work. These moments set a tone where cases and home life collide, and the 18 episodes of Season 2 give space to develop both threads.

The next few episodes continue that mix. ABC will air each new episode on Tuesday nights, with streaming available the following day on Hulu and Disney+.

Main cast returns

The principal cast returns, and their parts pick up directly from Season 1. Kaitlin Olson is back as Morgan Gillory, and the story keeps her at the heart of investigations while depicting how her choices affect her children.

Daniel Sunjata returns as Detective Adam Karadec, whose steady handling of evidence contrasts with Morgan’s instinctive leaps. Judy Reyes continues as Lieutenant Selena Soto, who balances department needs with Morgan’s unconventional values. These casting choices maintain the emotional center while allowing relationships to shift as stress rises.

New cast additions and the roles they play in High Potential Season 2

The High Potential Season 2 cast adds Steve Howey as a new precinct leader and Mekhi Phifer in a mysterious recurring role. Howey’s character appears as a captain who brings a different tone and takes on political and personnel decisions that change how cases move through the department. Phifer’s part is billed as connected to major crimes; press coverage keeps many details closed, which suggests writers plan to reveal him across several episodes.

Episode 1 shows the immediate threat and a clear choice for Morgan

In Episode 1, “Pawns,” Morgan faces the fallout from the Game Maker’s reemergence. The episode opens as Morgan, at home with her children, notices a man nearby whom she recognizes as a threat. Alarmed, she quickly ushers the kids to safety.

Meanwhile, detectives reopen a case with a familiar pattern to the Game Maker. Morgan insists on leveraging both LAPD resources and her observation skills, despite strong objections from colleagues.

Late in the episode, she implements extra security measures at home. The team narrows the suspect list, but Morgan’s promise to protect her children sparks tension within the squad as she pushes for aggressive action.

What to watch for in character shifts and relationships in the High Potential Season 2?

High Potential Season 2 deepens character histories, especially in early episodes. Episode 2 has Morgan clashing with Karadec after overruling protocol during a downtown operation, causing distrust between them. Episode 3 focuses on Morgan’s daughter acting out at school after a threat, forcing Morgan and her ex-husband into a tense meeting about custody. Episodes regularly show Karadec gathering evidence and reporting concerns while Morgan risks unorthodox solutions.

Trending

Watch out for how Morgan’s decisions reshape team dynamics and how the new cast members change command-level choices.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback