Wild online Stranger Things Season 5 theory claims Netflix cut important scenes: Here's what we think happened

Aashna
Did Netflix cut important scenes from Stranger Things Season 5? (Image via Instagram/@strangerthingstv)
Did Netflix cut important scenes from Stranger Things Season 5? (Image via Instagram/@strangerthingstv)

Did Netflix cut important scenes from Stranger Things Season 5? That’s the question igniting intense debate across social media as fans dissect every frame and unexplained narrative jump from the show’s final chapter.

Ever since Volume 2 dropped on Netflix on Christmas, viewers have been flooding Reddit, X and TikTok with theories suggesting that key scenes were either trimmed down or removed entirely, leaving noticeable gaps in character arcs and story logic. Many fans have claimed Netflix has trimmed down important scenes like Vecna's arc with Will, a fake-out death scene and a one-on-one Will and Mike montage concluding the former's coming-out arc from Stranger Things Season 5.

The speculation gained momentum after fans began comparing early teasers, behind-the-scenes interviews and pre-release comments from the Duffer Brothers with what actually made it to the screen. While separating fact from fiction is nearly impossible, eager Stranger Things fans have signed an official online petition for the streaming juggernaut to release cut scenes from the final season.

More on the Stranger Things Season 5 theory in our story.


Fans debate over deleted scenes in Stranger Things Season 5

After years of anticipation and build-up, Netflix finally released Stranger Things Season 5, which dropped the first two volumes, setting the stage for the series' finale on New Year's Eve. While Volume 1 concluded on a high note, with the shocking reveal of Will's transformation, the aftermath in Volume 2 was equally underwhelming, with fans calling it the weakest season of the show yet.

Fans were anticipating a grand set-up for the Stranger Things Season 5 finale in the penultimate episode titled The Bridge. Instead, the episode felt rushed and disappointing, with audiences even calling it "artificial" and "joyless'' online. Additionally, The Bridge is officially the lowest-rated episode in the series (5.8/10) on IMDb, surpassing the previously lowest-rated episode titled The Lost Sister from Season 2. This downward trajectory has further fueled the 'cut Stranger Things scenes' theory, with fans demanding that Netflix release the deleted scenes.

This Stranger Things Season 5 theory stems from a Google doc that cites anonymous sources, highlighting deleted key moments between characters crucial to the narrative and characters' arcs. Now that the document has circulated all over social media, fans are demanding justice for the show. A Reddit user commented:

''Almost 2 hours of footage has been taken from us. Having been loyal to the show for a decade, we deserve better. It was Netflix that cut these scenes, not the writers...''

Why has this Stranger Things Season 5 theory taken the internet by storm?

Debating over the cut-scenes theory, another Reddit user commented:

''Omfg this is so obnoxious. Cut content is a part of production. Period. It happens with everything. You were not "robbed."

While 'production cuts' are always a part of movies/TV shows, fans are claiming Netflix cut important seasons in Stranger Things Season 5 to change the narrative, resulting in an underwhelming and undeserved conclusion to the Duffer Brothers' sci-fi saga. Many fans who are voicing their concerns are from the Byler (the official ship name for Mike Wheeler and Will Byers) community, who feel Will's coming-out arc was abrupt and handled poorly. In a hasty moment, Will comes out to his mother and friends, implicitly suggesting his longtime crush on Mike, which closes the 'Byler' chapter in the show.

But fans have noticed discrepancies in previous cast interviews and Volume 2, hinting that Netflix cut important scenes from the final chapter. They were also quick to point out the initial (and longer) runtimes for Episodes 5, 6 and 7, which were debunked by the Duffer Brothers themselves. Fans are now claiming that the streaming juggernaut made cuts at the last moment, tampering with important scenes in Stranger Things Season 5. One Reddit user voiced these concerns:

''2 hours worth of actual footage, is not “part of production”. Characters are completely out of character, and know things that haven’t been told/explained to them yet. Entire plot lines (heavily crucial to the FINAL SEASON of the show) are nowhere to be found. Volume 2 is currently an unfinished mess.''

While neither Netflix nor the Duffer Brothers has commented on the issue, actor Randy Havens, who plays Mr. Clarke in the series, has confirmed there were no deleted or additional scenes in Stranger Things Season 5 Part 2 (via his Instagram story). The actor wrote:

"There’s no secret Snyder cut of the show. Don’t believe everything some random a** tells you on the internet."

There’s no way for even the most devoted fans to verify the truth behind these alleged cut scenes but one thing is certain: Volume 2 felt like a mess. As many fans have voiced, the recent episodes felt rushed and not the epic conclusion fans were hoping for. While expectations from the finale are still high, fans are hoping their petition does a miracle, which already has 200,000 signatures.


Here's what we think about this wild Stranger Things Season 5 theory

If you are chronically online, chances are you have certainly come across this wild Stranger Things Season 5 theory, demanding the release of deleted scenes from the final season. While the theory is entirely built on speculation by disappointed fans, the narrative gaps and discrepancies in Volume 2 cannot be denied. It is quite possible that Netflix opted to make important cuts at the last moment, with respect to the longer runtimes or other behind-the-scenes production details.

While it is certainly difficult to pick sides before any official information/statement is released, fans' frenzy is understandable, considering the love for the series. Stranger Things Season 5 was one of the most anticipated projects for 2025, marketed as a conclusion to the summer hit that took the world by storm back in 2016. After the high-stakes cliffhanger of Volume 1, fans were expecting an equally worthy and deserving Volume 2 before the finale rolls out.

Since the recently released episodes failed to fulfill those expectations, fans are holding onto this wild theory, hoping for additional scenes that could fill the plot holes. Only time will reveal whether the finale can address every lingering question and deliver the kind of conclusion fans have been hoping for.

The Stranger Things Season 5 finale will premiere on Netflix on December 31.


For the latest scoops on your favorite TV shows and movies, follow SoapCentral.

Edited by Aashna