'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
Dateline has covered a lot of chilling crimes, but the Jason Payne case hits different because the timeline feels like a slow-motion nightmare. If you’ve ever wondered how a family went from living in their dream home to becoming the center of a murder story, this breakdown will help you understand the whole case step by step.
The case initially starts off with hope, then crashes into tragedy, and ends with two separate trials, both of which reach the same conclusion. It’s one of those stories that stays stuck in your head.
Dateline: House of Horrors - The dream that looked perfect from the outside
When Dateline revisited the Jason Payne story, it was impossible not to feel the weight of how normal everything looked in the very beginning. Nichole and Jason Payne had settled into a quiet home tucked deep in the woods of Quitman, Texas.
Their adopted son, Daniel, talked about those early days and said,
“She wanted this type of house and then she looked for it and she found it and she’s like, ‘This is it,’ and he made it happen. They were happy...did almost everything together and they (had) just a typical marriage.”
Nichole had two sons, Taylor and Daniel, before getting married to Jason. She later had two more kids with Jason. The family seemed normal: dividing weekend chores, sharing routines, and dreaming about the future. Even money troubles seemed to fade after Jason received a $900,000 settlement from a car accident.
A big house, a boat, and a peaceful life made everything look calm from the outside. But the NBC true crime show depicted how, behind that calm, the cracks were already forming. Nichole’s family would later tell NBC that things weren’t as perfect as everyone assumed. But in the moment, nobody imagined what was coming.
A sinister shift in the air...
The timeline flips sharply on December 11, 2007, the morning that would later become the core of Dateline’s House of Horrors episode. Jason Payne dialed 911 and said,
“My wife and my son are both shot. I need some help,”
He sounded panicked and was completely out of breath. According to what he told the detectives at the time, Nichole had stayed in bed sick that morning while he got their two youngest kids ready. He claimed that 16-year-old Taylor threw a fit and refused to go to school because he didn’t have his own phone.
In one of his police interviews, Jason said,
“I mean, just kind of ranting, and said he wasn’t going to school. I think he was mad over the cell phone.”
Jason said he took little Jackson to school, came back with toddler Remington, and walked into a scene no one could ever imagine. The NBC show explained that Nichole was found shot in the back of the head, still warm to the touch. Taylor was in his converted garage bedroom, already cold.
EMT Leah Courtney remembered it clearly and told Dateline,
“He’s blue, and, as cold as his body was, I knew there was no helping him.”
At first glance, police wondered if this was a tragic murder-suicide. But the timing didn’t add up, and it demonstrated how investigators quickly began doubting that theory.
The investigation that cracked the story open
This is the part of the Dateline timeline where everything starts to shift and feel way too off. Lt. Miles Tucker from the Wood County Sheriff’s Office told Dateline that Nichole’s body was still warm, yet Taylor was ice cold, which made him think.
"She obviously had not been there very long."
He told the show. However, he also mentioned how Taylor was the complete opposite of Nichole and that his body was extremely cold when touched. There was no way he could have shot her, given that he was already dead.
That wasn’t the only thing that made investigators stare harder at Jason. A white rag inside his truck had bright red blood on it. Tucker mentioned that the color meant that the blood was fresh, and later DNA tests confirmed it was Nichole’s blood. The NBC true crime show also explained that the Paynes were broke and that Jason would receive $100,000 from Nichole’s life insurance.
Nichole’s mom, Sherry, and her sister-in-law, Sarah, also described serious problems in the marriage. Sherry said on Dateline that her daughter “wasn’t happy that last couple years,” and Sarah said Nichole once told her that Jason had threatened her if she tried to leave.
With all of this piling up, investigators eventually arrested Jason almost ten months after the murders. The true crime show made it clear that the case was shifting fast, and the story was nowhere near over.
Two trials, a family’s pain, and a shocking twist
Jason Payne’s first trial ended in 2010 with a life sentence. Dateline covered how Nichole’s mother felt when that verdict came down, and Sherry told the show that it cleared Taylor’s name too, saying it was heartbreaking that someone had tried to "brand" a 16-year-old boy into "a murderer."
But the crime and the timeline take yet another turn in 2013 when his conviction was overturned because the appeals court stated that some testimony should not have been allowed.
That meant the entire family had to sit through another trial in 2016, and once again, Jason was found guilty. Nichole’s son Jackson told Dateline he was relieved and said,
“It brought a lot of weight off my chest knowing that my father, who's a murderer, is not going to be on the loose.”
Remington, who was only two when the murders happened, remembered the smell of blood and said that memories like that “don’t go away.”
Then came the twist that sounded like something out of a movie. Dateline reported that Jason’s mother, Faye, tried to get someone to threaten EMT Leah Courtney so her story would change. In a recording, Faye told her niece,
“Basically, you would be scaring this person.”
She was later arrested and eventually pleaded guilty. Her involvement in the case closed the loop on the timeline of the case.
When Dateline visited the Jason Payne case, the whole timeline felt like a crawl from hope to utter horror. A family who once dreamed of a nice, peaceful life in the woods ended up in one of the most unforgettable junctions of their lives.
Two trials, years of hope slipping away, and the voices of Nichole's family built a story that doesn’t ever end for them. Today, Jason Payne is still serving life in prison, and the people who loved Nichole and Taylor continue rebuilding their lives one day at a time.
Trending
Stay tuned to SoapCentral for more.
Reply
