"Looks nightmare fuel": Internet divided as Joe Rogan shows off realistic Sabrina Carpenter cake for his daughter's birthday

Joe Rogan, a well-known UFC commentator and podcast host, released images of a dessert that looked like pop diva Sabrina Carpenter in May 2025. Sideserf Cake Studio made his daughter's birthday cake, which was a piece of beauty. Rogan praised the creation on Instagram, calling it "incredibly delicious art." Sideserf Cake Studio is known for its lifelike edible art, and they have done similar work in the past that got a lot of attention. Rogan's choice shows that his daughter loves Carpenter's music, just as he has said in public before.

---

Fans' reaction as Joe Rogan shows off a realistic Sabrina Carpenter cake for his daughter's birthday

A post was added to the X.com handle of Dexerto, with the caption:

"Joe Rogan shows off realistic Sabrina Carpenter cake for his daughter's birthday"

The comment that was most highlighted on the post read:

"bro this cake looks nightmare fuel" (@PepeGoesCrypto on X.com)

The post had more comments, such as:

"The cake will haunt my dreams for years 🤣" (@FrankDoesMemes on X.com)

"who called it realistic its creepy" (@Tylerhughes_2 on X.com)

"Thats crazy!" (@KarlMetaX on X.com)

"looks like a haunted doll" (@vrsaljak on X.com)

The cake that resembles Sabrina Carpenter was met with scrutiny and mockery. Some people made fun of the cake, including how her eyes looked, while some said that it looked creepy.

---

Another post was added to the X.com handle of Sabrina Carpenter All-News 💋, with the caption:

"🎂| UFC commentator Joe Rogan ordered a Sabrina Carpenter inspired cake for his daughter's birthday. — The cake was made by Sideserf Cake Studio."

The post received comments such as:

"I was terrified until I finished reading the sentence" (@ummwtf2 on X.com)

"It looks scary" (@KoonPloo on X.com)

The comment section received some sarcastic words from fans and followers, who cited that the effort is creative, but is not very appealing to the eyes for an edible substance.

---

One more post was added to the X.com handle of Steve F, who wrote:

"The cake Joe Rogan got for his daughter. People can be amazing. Wish I was good at any art form 😂"

The fact that Joe Rogan chose to celebrate his daughter's birthday with a photorealistic Sabrina Carpenter cake shows how celebrity culture, fan expression, and edible art all come together in interesting ways. Some people say the piece is a tribute to young admirers and a sign of Sideserf's skill, while others think the degree of realism is creepy. Eventually, the narrative shows how the internet is always interested in extremes, where mockery, praise, and anxiety all live in perfect harmony.